Wednesday, August 13, 2008

Twist of fate

This story is one that has really pulled at my heart strings. And one that I am sure anyone with a child or planning a child has been tracking.
And below is the latest development:

Niketa, whose request for abortion was rejected by court, suffers a miscarriage
--> Niketa, whose request for abortion was rejected by court, suffers a miscarriage-->
Thu, Aug 14 02:28 AM
Eight days after the Bombay High Court rejected her petition to abort her foetus detected with a congenital heart problem, then in its 26th week, Mumbai schoolteacher Niketa Mehta suffered a miscarriage.
"Yes, there was a miscarriage," her husband Haresh Mehta told The Indian Express late on Wednesday. "It happened yesterday," he said. Niketa is well, Haresh (33), a stockbroker, added.
In a case that led to a nation-wide debate on abortion law, the Mehtas had filed a petition on learning about the complete congenital heart blockage during an echocardiogram in her 24th week of pregnancy. Their lawyer pleaded that extensive surgeries to implant a pacemaker and then further surgeries to change the pacemaker every five years would be economically unviable for the Mehtas, as well as traumatic for the child.
The Medical Termination of Pregnancy Act, 1971, does not permit a termination of pregnancy after 20 weeks.
Dr Nikhil Datar, 31-year-old Niketa's gynaecologist and a co-petitioner in the case, said the family had not informed him about the development.
Meanwhile, Dr Datar said he was still keen to take the matter forward with an appeal to the apex court. "We have not received a copy of the High Court order. We can move this forward only after we get a copy," he said.
Dismissing an application by Mehta, the court had observed that medical experts did not express any "categorical opinion that if the child is born it would suffer from serious handicaps."
A day after her plea for medical termination of pregnancy was rejected, Niketa had said: " I didn't want a nationwide discussion on abortion laws. I wanted a decision on my abortion. But now I will try to be happy and bring my child to this world."

I dont know how I would react in the circumstance. First to realise you are pregnant and feel the joy of bearing life within you. Then to learn that the child within you has a serious problem and could suffer and require extensive surgeries simply to survive. To reconcile yourself to the option of terminating the pregnancy, stifling your joy because you know that bringing a child to suffer thus into the world would be unfair. And then have to move court for the right to terminate that pregnancy, have your plea turn into a national debate on abortion rights. And then see your plea rejected. And then reconcile yourself again to bearing the baby, and seeing it through till birth. And now this. Losing the baby through natural miscarriage.

I know for a fact that my husband's primary objection to my having a second child is the issues we faced with the brat. And the fact that the risks intensify with maternal age. And I agree. Despite my desire for a child, I know it would be terribly unfair to take the gamble and bring a child into this world knowing fully that the child might not be like other children. That every day would be a struggle, and I would live my life in fear of dying the next day and leaving the child at the mercy of the uncaring world. Any parent who is a caregiver to a chronically ill child, or a child with a developmental disorder knows, everyday is a battle. Every moment is a struggle, both for the child and the parent. And the world is cruel and uncaring. As long as the parents are around, the child is insulated against it.

I wonder what I would have done in Nikita's situation. I wonder how I would be feeling at this moment. I wonder about the poor child who was not destined to live.

11 opinions:

Aneela Z said...

But were whatever probs you had with Brat (and which fingers crossed he is getting over with) genetic? or were they just part of a problematic birthing process...with the exception of my mom, ALL the mommies (including my grand mother) were the other side of 30..even 35 when they became first time moms (and the ones after)..and there are many other moms I know who are 36 and counting (and had healthy babies)..so please please take all these warnings against "late latif" moms with a pinch of salt...yes there are risks but there are also 20 something moms with differently abled children. and there are some things (as my friends assure me) that one should leave to the One Who Resides Upstairs.

Mama - Mia said...

i cant even imagine the agony of the mehtas right now. I guess all the stress and media glare and incessant debates took a toll on her health...

am sure even now there will be people who will say maybe it wasnt natural miscarriage! :(

i hope that they have sttength to get over this tragedy and have a fulfiling life eventually

and i admire your strength and courage Kiran. You are a rock-solid woman! :)

hugs

abha

Anonymous said...

a child so unwanted, unloved and branded defective would have a tough time.

the child comes through us, it is not us, nor does it belong to us. as parents why can't we just love and let go? who are we to say what is normal or not?

should every blind foetus be aborted? how about the deaf, dumb? who's to say the child would not have been lived a happy, contented life?

parents need to be less competitive. they all want to be part of the rat race, and anything less than fully functional, speedy rats is going to be rejected and ejected.

Minka said...

RIP Niketa's baby. You would have had a tough life . If not health problems, then emotional ones from knowing you were unwanted in the first place. And it doesn't make your mother a monster because she knew she didn't have the mental strength to do it.

Aneela Z said...

basically what im trying to say in my long-winded way...a woman's body and choices are her own, whether its when she chooses to procreate or when she decides to abort. and we should respect her for that rather than "fear" her for rocking the "conventional boat".

Mamma mia! Me a mamma? said...

May the baby finaly rest in peace. And may the Mehta's be left in peace. All this unwanted media attention on a choice they must have struggled with could only have been testing.

They need to catch their breath after the roller-coaster ride that they have just been on.

M*4

Kiran said...

Whether to have a baby or not, what age to have it, whether they should give birth to a baby with confirmed birth defects or not are all personal choices. Its so unfortunate that the courts and media got involved with the Mehtas personal turmoil. Poor them, cant imagine the fatigue from all of this.

GettingThereNow said...

Even I have struggled with this fear Kiran - what will happen to my daughters if something were to happen to me. Sure J would love them, sure their grandparents would love them to bits - but no one would care for them like I do. No?

I know it must be so tough to go through so much for Nikita. May she find the strength.

Nat said...

It's hard and right now she must be swamped with a host of feelings the least of which would be confusion, guilt and sorrow. cant imagine her trying for another one with this kind of stress surrounding this trauma.
I think its the same for a lot of us Kiran even if you're at a 'safe' age or not...nowadays you have to decide to draw the line at one kid or two kids or whatever depending on your income and the time and care you're able to provide. I know I'd like to have four but things are not the same as they were when we were kids. Caring, educating and raising them takes a lot of energy, planning and finance than ever.
So the yearning you're going through? Take heart in the fact that you're not alone. :)

Cuckoo said...

What a trauma to be in the face of public opinions and half hour long discussions on every news channel on an issue that is SO personal. It is a triple tragedy for them... finding out that their baby has a heart problem, the court rejecting their petition and finally miscarrying the baby. I truly feel sorry for her.

The media today has become so horribly sensationalist that all personal feelings are relegated to the dusty attics every time a small or big story breaks out. Manjee is the other one that I thought was unnecessarily talked about.

karmickids said...

Aneela: The problems have not gone. They have lessened in severity substantially, but they're there. And I to be honest, would not like to knowingly bring another child into this world knowing of the risks involved, given I'm 38 now.

Abha: Nah Abha, I am a lily livered covered. And yes, there are already insinuations that they've gone in for a MTP, poor people.

Anon: True. We're fast reaching the sci fi reality of a Gattaca like world.

Minka: Amen. It would be heartbreaking.

Aneela: In an idealistic world it should be, but unfortunately it isnt. And that is the biggest tragedy. A woman's body is still not her own to make her choices.

Mamma:I empathise with them, but I am also grateful that their case has in a way given rise to debate on the issue.

Kiran: So true. Something so personal has been converted into a media circus.

Cee: Isnt that a very very tangible fear that we mothers have! I wonder if the fathers feel it as acutely as we do.

Nat: Thanks dear, looks like there are a many in the same boat.

Cuckoo: True, there seems to be absolutely zero sensitivity these days when it comes to reporting news. And that is the worrying

Post a Comment